Goldilocks and the Five Earthquakes

78

By Greekgeek

Goldilocks waits for a real earthquake.
See all 4 photos
Goldilocks waits for a real earthquake.

A True Story of My Earthquake Experiences

Once upon a time, a blond not-so-young lady from the wild and woodchuck-infested forests of Pennsylvania moved to the west coast. Bye-bye woodchucks, forests and rain; hello coyotes, wildfires and earthquakes.

Unusually, this girl from the edge of Amish country had once experienced a very small earthquake as a child -- around Easter -- or else a small, invisible freight train had once driven under my parents' house. That's what it had felt and sounded like. But that was a long time ago, and I was eager to experience a real earthquake.

Not too big: I didn't want anyone hurt. Not too small: I knew what that was like. A 5.5, I thought, would be just right.

Hector Mine Quake: M7.1

Aerial photo of the surface rupture from the Hector Mine Quake (1999), cutting the desert near Joshua Tree. And to think I was trying to go out there for a star party that night, only my sleeping bag hadn't dried, so I didn't. Drat!
Aerial photo of the surface rupture from the Hector Mine Quake (1999), cutting the desert near Joshua Tree. And to think I was trying to go out there for a star party that night, only my sleeping bag hadn't dried, so I didn't. Drat!

This Earthquake Is Too Big

There were a couple of tantalizing bumps and wobbles. One night, it felt like a dump truck dropped an invisible dumpster just outside: or rather, it felt like something had dropped the whole dump truck. That was interesting but small, probably a 3 or 4 centered right under me. Finally, in 1999, it happened: a real, no-doubt-about-it earthquake. This was a lengthy rolling earthquake that set the apartment creaking and the drapes swinging. Working late, I jumped up from my chair and hurried outside onto the porch.

Under a balcony.

Under glass windows.

Under several awnings.

Putting the lie to stories about psychic animals, my cat slept right through the start of the shaking. She would have slept through the whole thing if I hadn't run back inside to carry her onto the porch. She protested vigorously. SHE knew you don't stand right where broken glass, masonry, and other stuff cracking off the outside of a building can fall right on your head.

Luckily, it was not a severe quake, although it was spectacular. Transformers blew all around my neighborhood, lighting the night sky with blue flashes like a massive thunderstorm. Dogs barked and howled. Every single car alarm went off. Afterwards, I turned on the TV to hear: "If you're seeing this broadcast, you're one of the few." But that was all.

The damage elsewhere was slight, since the epicenter was 30-50 miles from cities. A train derailed, but the only injury was a dislocated hip. Desert residents had the contents of their trailers, homes and stores thrown around like tossed salad. The Disney Hotel sign cracked. There was other minor damage, mostly bricks falling from building façades.

A few months earlier, another 7.2 earthquake had leveled the Turkish city of Izmet and killed perhaps 35,000 people. It was sobering to realize what a difference quake-proofing and building codes make, although liquefaction and proximity to the epicenter also played a role.

Chino Hills Earthquake, 5.5

Californians know to go to the USGS "Did You Feel It?" webpage to report what they felt and see the shakemap.
Californians know to go to the USGS "Did You Feel It?" webpage to report what they felt and see the shakemap.

This Earthquake Is Too Small

Almost ten years later, I experienced another, very wimpy earthquake, the kind that makes the evening news chiefly by throwing goods off store shelves and dumping them on the floor.

This earthquake was a shake-shake-shaker, like a juddering train. It wasn't very strong, and it was over almost as soon as it began. I stayed at my desk, instead of getting under it for safety.

I still hadn't learned the right thing to do in an earthquake.

This store clerk moved towards the door because of things falling, but probably should have found a place to "Drop, Cover, and Hang On." Judge Judy did exactly the right thing:

Judge Judy: The Motion Does Not Rest

7.2 Baja Earthquake, Apr 2010

Shakemap from USGS. That line is the length of the surface rupture!
Shakemap from USGS. That line is the length of the surface rupture!
Source: USGS

This Earthquake Is Also Too Big

On Easter Sunday, 2010, almost exactly 26 after my Easter egg decorating in Pennsylvania was interrupted by a very small earthquake, I experienced another, much larger earthquake. The epicenter was 150 miles away.

This one was impressively loud, rumbling and creaking. It's the first time I've ever seen the walls, ceiling and floor of a room ripple with visible waves like sheets of aluminum. The cat bolted into the bedroom and disappeared under the bed. I hopped out of my chair and ran to my office door to hold on. BZZZZT! Still not the right thing to do!

There were no deaths, thankfully, but injuries and a lot of toppled homes and buildings in Mexicali. YouTube was inundated with San Diegans filming swimming pools imitating a wave tank. (Also see this amazing video -- strong language warning -- of the mountains throwing up huge amounts of dust from the shock).

Earthquake Preparedness

Until now, I had relied vaguely on my camping gear, freeze-dried camping food, a few gallons of water, and extra cat food/litter stored in the garage. The Easter 2010 quake was a wake-up call that I needed to get organized. I saw a lot of homes in Mexicali that had collapsed over the garage, which is the vulnerable point of most houses, and I realized I might not have access to my garage. I knew, too, that in the "Big One," we would be without power and water for days, and the roads might be obstructed. It was time to get serious and make sure I could shelter in place for a week.

Using this earthquake preparedness checklist, I collected and organized earthquake supplies in my car (under-the-trunk suitcase compartments are handy!) and in a bin on my back patio, accessible from outside. Storing camping supplies outside in a locker is also a good idea.

Californians React to a 5.7 Earthquake

This Earthquake Is Just Right

Two months later, a 5.7 aftershock was the best earthquake yet: almost no damage, just swaying like a floating dock in a marina. It was an odd earthquake; I and many SoCal residence felt seasick, even though it wasn't as strong as the one before. In fact, I felt queasy for a few days.

But this was a good earthquake: strong enough to be exciting without being dangerous. In fact, it was fun! Check out the standing ovation from these baseball fans:


Drop, Cover and Hold On

Here's the important thing. I finally got it right: Drop, Cover and Hold On. As soon as the shaking started, I went under the bar in the kitchen.

The old wisdom about moving to a doorway in an earthquake comes from photos of old buildings in the southwest, made of mud-brick (adobe): clay crumbles, while wood-frame doors stay up. But wood-frame homes flex. Unless buildings are made of brick, stone or unreinforced concrete, or they're sitting on floodplain soils or landfill which can liquefy, they are unlikely to collapse. A much more common danger is getting hit by things flying off shelves, glass popping out of windows or light fixtures and tiles falling from the ceiling. So drop and get under a desk or next to heavy (non-glass!) furniture. Hold on in case it's a big one.

Evacuate the building after it's all over, but watch out for glass and fallen debris.

Poll: Earthquake insurance yea or nay?

If you lived in southern California, would you pay the high premium for homeowners' earthquake insurance?

  • Yes, I'd buy it (or I have)
  • No, it's a few thousand dollars a year I can't afford.
See results without voting

Tweets (yellow) outrace seismic waves

Comments

jaykatt profile image

jaykatt 9 months ago

Very interesting, useful, and also humorous. Good writing all around. I keep getting these little reminders of how unprepared I am. I wonder how many people who live through disasters never thought it would happen to them? Because I'm guilty of that kind of thinking too. Doesn't help that I'm a native Californian and have been through so many minor earthquakes that I hardly take them seriously anymore....voted up interesting and useful.

Greekgeek profile image

Greekgeek Hub Author 9 months ago

Jaykatt, thanks for the comment!

Most of us put off preparedness. I moved to California in 1996 and didn't really get organized until that Mexicali earthquake 14 years later. And perhaps, being from out of state, I was more impressed.

But I know exactly what you mean. When I lived back east, I never stocked much in case of blizzards. And I am keenly reminded this week of where I was as Hurricane Gloria was approaching: perched in the top branches of a 16-foot pine tree, going, "OooooOOOOooOO!" as the wind began to whip up, while my sitter tried desperately to talk me down and get me inside.

With me, it's not that I think it won't happen... I believe we're going to get thwacked with a 7+ close to home sooner or later, if we live long enough. I just put off getting ready, and/or blithely assume we'll muddle through somehow.

eregouf profile image

eregouf Level 1 Commenter 9 months ago

This was a great story about some rather small quakes, but it was still interesting. One of the most devastating hit San Francisco in the early 1900's. Lots of death from falling buildings but worst was the fire that raged without letup for days!!

Greekgeek profile image

Greekgeek Hub Author 9 months ago

eregouf: yeah, I'm still waiting for the REALLY big one. There's debate over the magnitude of the Great SF Quake of 1906, since seismometers weren't yet common, but it was probably a high 7 (7.8 or so). Fire codes mean it won't be quite so bad next time (less lamps/stoves/open flames also helps). Hopefully building codes will help mitigate the damage, too, but unfortunately a lot of SF is built on fill, like the Marina district, which liquefies. That's tough.

Amazingly, the Chilean and Tohohu quakes of the last year were both 9s, making them ~1000 times more powerful than the San Francisco earthquake! It's a credit to both countries the physical damage wasn't worse. Their construction stood up to the quake itself just fine; Japan's problem was the tsunami that followed.

eregouf profile image

eregouf Level 1 Commenter 9 months ago

Dear greekgeek Thank you for your reply. Of course the biggest ever recorded was TOBA

Greekgeek profile image

Greekgeek Hub Author 9 months ago

Wow, yes. Toba was a huge event. We're lucky we're here to know about it.

Just for clarity, in case anyone's reading our geology geeking -- Toba was an ENORMOUS volcanic eruption some time around 74,000 years ago (assuming you trust the geological record) that caused a worldwide catastrophe. It was a supervolcano a little bit like Yellowstone, or like Mt. Pinatubo only much, much, much larger. Modern genetics has found a bottleneck in the human genome around that time, suggesting that the eruption nearly wiped out the human race. The ash fall would've been global and might have blocked out the sun for a few years.

That's a volcano. Technically, the largest *recorded* earthquake is the Valdivia Earthquake in Chile 1964, which was a 9.4. To put that in perspective, that's about a thousand times stronger than the great San Francisco quake of '06, and more than ten thousand times stronger than the one that just hit the east coast. Yikes!

Even 7s like the ones I've been through are not really small quakes, but I haven't been near the epicenter of one yet. If I live here long enough, I expect to find out what a 7 feels like near the epicenter. I think I'm ready for it. I'm NOT ready for a 9. My hat is off to Chile and Japan for making buildings strong enough to survive that. (If only Japan hadn't gotten a tsunami, too, it would've been okay.)

eregouf, thanks for the reply, too. I'm not a geologist, but I've been fascinated by earthquakes and volcanoes all my life. Other people go to Hawaii for the beaches; I go for the volcano!

Submit a Comment
Members and Guests

Sign in or sign up and post using a hubpages account.



    • No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked
    • Comments are not for promoting your Hubs or other sites

    Please wait working